Marc writes:
We don’t talk about it, BUT… In my humble opinion, Lin-Manuel Miranda is a musical genius. I can never fit all the words in, but I always find myself either tapping along or wanting to try and join in his music. Off the top of my head, be it Hamilton, Moana, In the Heights, Vivo, or Encanto (and there will be much more!), I appreciate his brilliance.
Whilst “We Don’t Talk About Bruno” might be a one-hit wonder simply because there are so many people performing in it as individuals, it is also the first (and at this point, only) time a Disney original song topped the music charts… Which I think gives it a bit more kudos… But why did this particular song capture so many hearts and minds!?
Maybe it’s because we all have those things we don’t want to talk about. Maybe it’s because we’ve all had those times when people have said things to us that we didn’t want to hear. Perhaps it’s because so many (dare I say “all”?) of us tend to carry around baggage, and hurt, and resentment that we don’t want to talk about? Or maybe it’s better for the peace if there are some things that we just let remain unspoken?
Yet, this song are the worms that spring out when the can is opened, when someone dares to speak about the elephant in the room, about the empty seat at the table…
To go into the song, Mirabel says the line “What if you didn’t understand what he saw?” I’ll not spoil the film for you if you haven’t seen it, but what if the silence wasn’t justified? What if the resentment wasn’t merited? What if things being aired sooner helps them change faster and leads to understanding and reconciliation? … But I won’t spoil the film for you…
What do we do when people say things we don’t want to hear?
How well does it work for us when we try and brush them under the carpet?
When did anything change simply because we stopped talking about it?
Or if we are actually still talking about it, how are we framing what we’re saying?
It’s a song about the things we know are there, but we try and hide. It’s a song about resentment, hurt and unresolved conflict. It is a challenge about forgiveness and shame, and maybe even guilt. There’s some stuff about how we deal with prophets too, and whether we shoot the messenger for reading, and understanding, and proclaiming the inevitable.
Ah, the simple depth of Disney in resonating with the story of not just children but of all of us.
What aren’t we talking about? Should we keep it bottled up or deal with it?
…
Find out more about Encanto at https://www.disney.co.uk/movies/encanto



