Richard writes:
‘While you make pretty speeches, I’m being cut to shreds’
‘My body’s floating down the muddy river’
When I was a small child, television consisted of just three channels – difficult to imagine these days. It was at least, in general, more of a communal experience than the way in which we connect with our screens today. The weekend was often dominated by family entertainment programmes like Sunday Night at the London Palladium. One of the most famous programmes of the time was Bruce Forsyth’s Generation Game, where contestants joined in short plays, dancing and games of skill before playing a final memory game at the end of the show – what you could remember you took home. Occasionally the show would feature a plate spinner who would attempt to spin more and more plates on top of vertical poles, hoping to keep them aloft without any falling to the ground. The act has ancient roots in Chinese acrobatic troupes who performed in groups, twirling and spinning plates in carefully choreographed movements and contortions. But in the Music Hall and circus traditions, it became a solo act often part of a comedy routine. One plate spinner, David Spathaky, once managed to keep 108 plates spinning at once, still a world record. It passed for entertainment then!
The phrase ‘spinning plates’ carries with it the sense of keeping too many balls in the air, of doing so many things that we feel overwhelmed, even perhaps crushed and destroyed. The Radiohead song, Like Spinning Plates, features on the album Amnesiac although a beautiful plain piano version is also available on the live album, I Might be Wrong. It began as an accident. The band recorded an unsuccessful version of the song I Will, which eventually found its way onto Hail to the Thief. Rather than discard the recording, they reversed the instrumental, creating a dissonant landscape onto which Thom Yorke’s lyrics could be projected. The reversal creates a mood of discomfort, of floating backwards, of deep disconnection in which a voice struggles for connection in the midst of emotional turmoil. It is a contemporary form of lamentation in which the singer expresses a sense of disintegration which works on a number of levels: personal, social and ecological. It is a song about being overwhelmed and traumatised by external pressures; of unease and disillusionment; of struggling to keep the plates spinning in a world where public words no longer bridge the divide but ring hollow and simply open up the ground between us.
While you make pretty speeches, I’m being cut to shreds
It is a world in which the plates feel fragile, about to fall from a height. How can they keep on spinning when the world is fractured, and my body feels like it’s floating in a muddy river?
The prophet Ezekiel seems an unlikely spiritual companion for Radiohead. Yet the prophet finds himself amongst exiles in a context of national ruin and loss of identity, adrift in a reality which overwhelms him. He is crushed, stunned into silence (3:15), traumatised, as he sits amongst his people, with his speech and movement shut down. Yet he offers a profound insight into a different kind of overwhelming. Sometimes we cannot escape the destructive forces that attempt to overwhelm us. Prophetic wisdom offers us ways of living within the ruins until the time when the landscape begins to change. In life, there are all kinds of overwhelmings, some of which are destructive, others of which are life-giving. Ezekiel offers us a way of comprehending reality which invites us to re-orientate our lives on God precisely at the point when it feels that we are dis-orientated and dis-connected. He offers us an invitation to re-order our lives on a stable centre which, whilst it does not remove the external threat, begins to provide us with a base from which we might prevent it from crushing us and perhaps even eventually subdue it. This re-ordering or re-centring has many names but is often found in practices like prayer, worship and community – the wellsprings of vocational identity.
One of the most famous chapters in Ezekiel, chapter 47, offers a vision of a new overwhelming. It is a vision not of a muddy river but of water flowing from the Temple like a life-giving stream. It is a vision of a new Eden which provides an alternative to a lament of disconnection and dissonance. As the text tells us, everything will live where the river goes (v.9).
…
Find out more about Radiohead at https://radiohead.com/
